Bill Plaschke: Remembering the college professor who helped launch his career

If you ever had a college professor who had a profound influence on your career, then you can relate to this Bill Plaschke column in the Los Angeles Times. A very nice read.

Plaschke writes:

His name was Bill Ward. He put down his red pen, tilted his head in my direction, and glared. I was overcome with such fear and insecurity, I blurted out words so bold that even I couldn’t have possibly believed them.

“I’m going to be the best writer to ever come out of this department!” said the kid who wrote badly.

Professor Ward’s glare slowly became a soft smile, followed by what sounded like a sarcastic chuckle. He then delivered a most enduring message, not only in what he said, but what he didn’t say.

He didn’t tell me was I wrong. He didn’t tell me to get lost. He didn’t discourage me with the obvious reality that I was a nobody in the middle of nowhere.

He simply looked at me from over his glasses and said, “We’ll see.”

For a lost kid with no resume, it is impossible to describe how empowered I felt by the words, “We’ll see.” With that statement, Professor Ward had created an environment where everyone would be given a fair chance, where even the worst of budding journalists would be evaluated with no judgment, no bias, and best of all, no ceilings.

Professor Ward’s first lesson was that it was OK to dream. And then he taught me to write.

And this.

“Write like you talk,” he would say, and by now most folks know I talk fast and in spurts.

Those descriptions that sometimes color my writing a deep shade of purple and make even me wince? Yep, Professor Ward, who had a simple mantra that I follow today.

“Show me, don’t tell me,” he would say.

Professor Ward taught those lessons to a generation of budding SIUE journalists with a loud snort and an iron fist. He was my toughest editor. He was my harshest reader. He ran our small and obscure department as if it were a daily newspaper. If your copy was filled with typos or misspellings, you flunked the assignment. If you missed any deadline, you flunked the project.

RIP Jean Beliveau: Classy Montreal great was true giant of the game

Hockey, especially Montreal, is in mourning today with the passing of the great Jean Beliveau.

For fans of my generation, Beliveau was a terrific player to watch, representing the excellence of those great Canadian teams who won 10 Stanley Cups during his career.

Plus he had of the one great names in sports that sings off your tongue: Jean BELL-i-VO.

Take a look at highlights of his career and his appearance on “To Tell The Truth” in 1957.


Ratings: Notre Dame hardly golden for Fox; Iron Bowl ties record for ESPN

How much of a difference does two years make? Plenty when it comes to ratings for Notre Dame.

Two years ago, ABC pulled a massive 10 overnight rating for major markets for the Irish’s victory at USC, which propelled them into the national title game against Alabama; 1 ratings point is the equivalent of more than 1 million homes.

Saturday, USC’s rout over the floundering Domers only did a 1.5 overnight on Fox, down 85 percent from the 2012 game.

According to Sports Media Watch, Saturday’s rating was the second-lowest of the year for Notre Dame. Only the opener against Rice, which did a 1.4 rating on NBC, was worse.

Meanwhile, ESPN was the big winner Saturday night with the Alabama-Auburn game. The Iron Bowl did a 7.2 overnight rating, tying the highest ever for a regular-season college football game on the network. USC-Ohio State in 2009 also did a 7.2.

Also, how great was it to hear Brent Musburger on the call of a big game? I know things change, but Brent still can bring it.

 

Precedent: Credit Sports Illustrated with assist in ESPN’s as-told-to story with Janay Rice

My latest column for the National Sports Journalism Center at Indiana examines the Janay Rice story on ESPN.com.

From the column:

******

It is interesting to note that ESPN turned to a competitor to help justify using the as-told-to format for Jemele Hill’sinterview with Janay Rice that ran Friday on ESPN.com.

In an in-house ESPN Front Row piece written by high-ranking network PR exec Josh Krulewitz, Vince Doria, the senior vice-president and director of news, noted as-told-to stories aren’t “uncommon.”

“A notable recent example was LeBron James announcing his return to Cleveland in Sports Illustrated,” Doria said.

Then in an interview conducted via email with Richard Deitsch of SI.com, Hill wrote:

“The partnership was unusual for me because I’d never done it before, but it’s not really unusual in these times. Sports Illustrated has published as-told-to pieces with Jason Collins and LeBron James, for example.”

Well, if it’s good enough for SI, it must be good enough for ESPN. The folks in Bristol owe you one.

Indeed, the recent Sports Illustrated precedents likely helped convince ESPN to relinquish some of its editorial control to Rice. There’s little question that her first-person piece is powerful and highly compelling. It undoubtedly generated immense traffic for ESPN.com during a holiday weekend filled with turkey and football.

Yet as is often the case, there is a price to be paid. It came in the form of howls that ESPN compromised its journalistic integrity with its arrangement with Rice.

Howard Kurtz, Fox News: “Approval — really? How is that different from a press release? Don’t public figures have to hire P.R. firms for this sort of thing?

“And this is the hilarious part: ‘No questions were off limits.’ What does it matter, if Janay Rice can cut out anything she doesn’t like? I don’t know what this piece was, but it wasn’t journalism.”

David Zurawik, Baltimore Sun: “In effect what ESPN did is surrender editorial control to Janay and Ray Rice and their attorneys and publicists. ESPN handed over its many platforms to Janay and Ray Rice and their handlers and loaned out one of their reporters to record and help Janay tell her story ‘in her own words.’ Wow. I hope it was worth it in page views and plays.”

Erik Wemple, Washington Post: “Now back to the question at hand, which is whether ESPN cheated its audience by allowing this sweetheart interview deal. The answer is, probably. Thanks to the deal’s terms, we won’t know what revelations didn’t get passed along.”

Joe Concha, Mediaite.com: “This is no longer a tell-all discussion, it’s simple dictation…with Hill morphing from journalist to stenographer.”

Ouch. Concha’s allegation that Hill was as unengaged as a stenographer is a low blow. Hill is a solid journalist. Clearly, an interview did take place with Rice answering Hill’s questions.

The argument even could be made that the as-told-to format actually produced a more compelling piece. Readers got a better idea of who Janay Rice is and how this experience impacted her. A conventional news story likely wouldn’t have detailed her background or how she and Ray Rice went through couple’s therapy prior to getting married. The format humanized Janay Rice as someone who doesn’t want to be known just for being a victim of domestic violence.

******

Link to the rest of the column.

 

 

Matt Lauer talks with Janay Rice: Hill defends ESPN’s as-told-to interview

Ray and Janay Rice continue to dominate the news. Here is Matt Lauer’s interview with Janay Rice on “Today”  this morning.

Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Meanwhile, Richard Deitsch at SI.com did an email interview with Jemele Hill about her as-told-to interview with Janay Rice that ran on Friday on ESPN.com.

How comfortable were you writing the piece in Janay’s voice, as opposed to incorporating her answers into a third-person narrative into which you could have infused additional reporting?

The partnership was unusual for me because I’d never done it before, but it’s not really unusual in these times. Sports Illustrated has published as-told-to pieces with Jason Collins and LeBron James, for example. In my case, it was truly a collaboration. It was not a dictatorship. The piece that was published is very close to the original draft that she received. The piece was edited by our editors and any changes she suggested either involved accuracy, her giving more information or offering a more concise explanation.

I know people are skeptical because Janay had approval over the final product. But I take a lot of pride in being a journalist. I would never have been comfortable with leaving out anything that compromised my journalistic integrity. As a network, we wouldn’t have stood for that. Throughout this process, everyone at ESPN had the unofficial pact that we would walk away from this if we felt it jeopardized our credibility. And for her perspective, it would have not have done her any good to undermine the process. At some point, she was going to have to face these questions. She wanted the same thing I wanted — to tell the most complete story.

 

Dispute: Dish subscribers could be blacked out for their regional sports networks

If you are a Dish subscriber in Chicago, San Francisco, or the DC-Baltimore area, you might have a hard time watching your favorite team after tonight.

Robert Channick of the Chicago Tribune reports on a dispute between Dish and Comcast-owned regional networks in those areas.

When the Chicago Bulls host the Dallas Mavericks on Tuesday night, speculation will run rampant over how much injury-plagued superstar Derrick Rose will play.

Hundreds of thousands of Chicago-area Dish Network subscribers may have a bigger question: Where is the game?

Comcast SportsNet Chicago, which is carrying the game, is perhaps days from being blacked out by the satellite provider in a dispute over license fees. The current agreement expires Monday and Dish Network is balking at an increase demanded by CSN.

At stake is CSN Chicago’s slate of Bulls, Blackhawks, White Sox and Cubs games and its other sports programming, a local fan staple for 10 years. Dish has more than 342,000 subscribers in the Chicago area who would be affected by such a blackout, according to media research firm SNL Kagan.

The dispute also involves CSN Mid-Atlantic (Washington and Baltimore area), CSN Bay Area (San Francisco-Oakland) and CSN California (Northern California and parts of Oregon and Nevada), all of which may be dropped by Dish next week.

Seems to be a wide impasse.

“Comcast SportsNet is demanding a 40 percent price increase for more than 90 percent of Dish customers in each of the affected markets, when only a small fraction of those consumers actually watch the channels,” Dish said in a statement.

Sources familiar with the negotiations say NBCUniversal, which operates the regional sports networks after being acquired by Comcast last year, may be seeking closer to a 10 percent increase across the four markets.

“We are seeking to license our regional sports networks to Dish on the same terms that other distributors have accepted for this programming,” NBCUniversal said in a statement. “Our rates are reflective of the very high value of this programming, a value that is recognized by consumers through the increased ratings for these (regional sports networks).”

If you follow local sports in those areas and have Dish, might be time to think of an alternative.

 

Jim Nantz believes NFL’s Thursday slate is working; ‘Would sign up again in heartbeat’

My latest Chicago Tribune column, which ran yesterday, is on Jim Nantz discussing the issues of NFL games on Thursdays.

You also can access the column via @Sherman_Report.

From the column:

*******

The quality of Thursday games has been a controversial subject for the NFL this year. But don’t expect to hear any complaints from Jim Nantz.

Nantz and Phil Simms will be on the call for the Bears’ back-to-back Thursday encounters: Thanksgiving Day against the Lions on CBS and Dec. 5 against the Cowboys in Soldier Field on NFL Network.

Thanks to his Thursday-Sunday assignments, Nantz is in a stretch during which he will be working five games in 15 days. And the 55-year-old play-by-play voice is doing it with the challenge of traveling to five cities with his wife, Courtney, and their 8-month-old girl, Finley.

Nantz’s double-duty shifts on most weeks (he has a handful of Sundays off) are an unprecedented run for a NFL announcer. To use a variation of his trademark Masters line, it has been a year unlike any other for Nantz.

“That’s right,” Nantz said with a laugh. “But I feel very fresh. Nobody is going throw a pity party for me. I’m loving every minute of it.”

The same probably can’t be said of NFL players regarding these short-week games. The quick turnaround gives them little chance to recover from the previous Sunday’s game. As a result, critics contend there is a drop-off in speed and execution for the Thursday matchups.

It didn’t help matters when the Thursday night games were plagued by three straight routs early this year. Even Nantz wondered if some of the critical assessments were justified.

“I began to think whether teams had the extra gear to fight their way back into a game,” Nantz said. “Were they mentality and physically so low in energy that they couldn’t tap a reservoir to bounce back?”

Nantz now feels differently after watching NBC endure nine straight games where the margin was 18 points and higher on Sunday nights.

“(The blowouts weren’t) exclusive to Thursday night,” Nantz said.

 

DVR alert: CBS documentary on Verne Lundquist’s terrific career

Great announcer, great guy. Has stood the test of time.

The rundown from CBS:

******

CBS Sports debuts IN YOUR LIFE, a one-hour documentary celebrating Verne Lundquist’s 50 years in broadcasting, this Saturday, Nov. 29 (1:30 PM, ET) on the CBS Television Network.

The documentary follows Verne over the past year, his 50th as a broadcaster.  Verne has witnessed and called some of the greatest moments in sports history, from Jack Nicklaus’ birdie at the 1986 Masters® toChristian Laettner’s last-second shot to beat Kentucky in the 1992 NCAA Tournament. IN YOUR LIFE relives these indelible moments with Verne as the storyteller, and takes you through his incredible career.

To view a clip from the documentary where Verne recalls broadcasting Laettner’s buzzer beater, click here: http://on.fb.me/1xSlAYM

The documentary features interviews with those who were there with Verne during these memorable moments, both announcing and playing, such as Jim NantzBill RafteryDavid Feherty and Scott Hamilton. Verne made his broadcasting debut on August 31, 1963 at KTBC-TV in Austin, Texas, a station owned by President and Mrs. Lyndon Johnson.  Verne joined CBS Sports in 1982 and has called more than 20 different sports for the Network.  He is currently the lead college football play-by-play announcer calling the SEC ON CBS and Army-Navy game.  He also calls the Masters and PGA Championship and will announce his 31stconsecutive NCAA Tournament this year.

Richard Sherman was off base mocking NFL’s media, endorsement policies

As I wrote for the National Sports Journalism Center at Indiana, the Pro Football Writers Association of America hands out the annual Pete Rozelle Award to the league’s best public relations operation.

Somehow, I suspect the Seattle Seahawks won’t be winning the award this year. Things are getting out of hand in the Great Northwest.

Richard Sherman, with some help from Doug Baldwin, used his weekly press conference yesterday to mock the NFL’s fine of $100,000 to Marshawn Lynch for not talking to the media. And he protested some other NFL policies.

From Terry Blount of ESPN.com:

Seahawks cornerback Richard Sherman and receiver Doug Baldwin did a parody in front of reporters Tuesday, making a point of criticizing the NFL over fining teammate Marshawn Lynch $100,000 for not talking to the media.

Sherman and Baldwin’s little comedy routine focused on what they view as the NFL’s hypocritical policies over what players can and cannot say.

Sherman went to the lectern in the team’s auditorium and stood next to a cardboard cutout of Baldwin, who was crouched behind it.

Sherman: “You know the other day, Marshawn Lynch got fined $100,000. Did you know that? They wouldn’t have paid him $100,000 if he had talked [before the fine]. Doug, do you think they would have paid him?”

Baldwin: “No, they sure would not.”

Sherman: “Geez, Louise. But you know who pays me a lot of money? Beats by Dre, the wonderful headphones I wear. But the league doesn’t let me say anything about them. Doug, why is that?”

Baldwin: “I don’t know. Sounds kind of hypocritical to me.”

NFL policy states that players are not allowed to show or use items with non-NFL sponsor logos 90 minutes before or after games.

And the act went on. Sherman also knocked the league for having beer companies as sponsors and for disregarding player safety by scheduling Thursday games.

Entertaining stuff, to be sure. Also, curious to do it two days before a big game at San Francisco. If the Seahawks lose, there will be issues of whether Sherman’s act was a distraction.

Here’s the point that Sherman, Lynch and probably many other players don’t understand. The NFL isn’t acting unilaterally with its policies on the media and endorsements.

The NFL Players Association has to sign off on these policies. If Sherman, Lynch have a problem, they should direct their protests to the NFLPA.

Also, in the ESPN.com piece, which cited Darren Rovell as a contributor, there’s this passage.

NFL players actually get 45 percent of the money generated from league endorsement deals, as that money then becomes part of the salary cap. A player like Sherman benefits indirectly from the league’s Bose headphones deal and gets paid by Apple, which owns competitor Beats By Dre.

Sherman has also been a direct beneficiary of an NFL deal. He is the spokesman for Campbell’s Chunky Soup, which is an official sponsor of the league.

That’s right, brother Sherman, you get paid for the league’s endorsements. More importantly, so do all the other players, including back-ups and special teammers, who aren’t as fortunate to have their own endorsement deals like you. The league has to maintain the integrity of its sponsors on game day.

Also, regarding the Thursday night games, Sherman and the players benefit there too. The games are worth at least $500 million in TV revenue, with 45 percent going to the players. And let’s not forget, the NFLPA signed off on playing these Thursday night games.

If the players were truly against them, their association could have said, “No, we’re not playing.” Of course, that would have meant less money in the revenue pool, forcing them to take a pay cut.

The same holds true for the NFL taking in billions from beer sponsors. Have a problem with that, Richard? OK, but less money for you. You good with that?

As for the NFL’s media policy requiring players to talk, few players have exploited the exposure better than Sherman. It has helped make him a very rich man.

Sherman should remember that the next time he claims the NFL is being hypocritical for its policies.

 

Giving Thanks: Best slate of NFL Turkey day games in years

A good menu, no?

12:30 p.m. ET: Chicago at Detroit, CBS

4:30 p.m. ET: Philadelphia at Dallas, Fox.

8:30 p.m. ET: Seattle at San Francisco, NBC

It helps that Thanksgiving fixtures Detroit and Dallas have good teams. Especially the Lions after all those dismal Matt Millen turkeys.

However, the NFL also is carrying over the inner-division match-up concept for the Thursday night games to Thanksgiving Day. As a result, CBS doesn’t have an AFC team playing against the Lions. Instead, Jim Nantz and Phil Simms will be on the call for an important game between two old rivals in the NFC North.

“I was thrilled when I saw this game on our schedule,” said Nantz, who will be calling his 11th Thanksgiving game. “We benefit by not having a crossover game (an AFC team playing against Detroit). We have a great, traditional game. I love this match-up.”

Enjoy and have a great Thanksgiving.