New and social media helped trigger Sterling’s downfall

Thanks to Phil Barber of the Santa Rosa Press Democrat for including me in a piece about how new and social media helped trigger the events we saw today.

Barber writes:

If this were 1984 or 1994 or maybe even 2004, Sterling’s cringe-inducing words never would have made it to public ears, and he would have been sitting courtside at Oracle Arena in Oakland for Game 4 on Sunday. Thanks to the Internet and social media platforms and the ubiquity of hand-held computers, he became the biggest story of the weekend, and the groundswell of sentiment against him may be too massive to withstand.

And my quotes:

“It came out Saturday, right?” Ed Sherman, who writes about sports media at his site ShermanReport.com, said of the Sterling story. “So then boom, it’s on ESPN the whole day. Then you’ve got TNT (basketball coverage), and those guys get to weigh in, and then all that stuff gets posted … via either social media or YouTube. It all kind of feeds on itself, and you’ve got this big boulder that keeps getting bigger and bigger, and it’s rolling right toward Sterling.”

And…

“I wish I had a dime for every time I heard the word ‘allegedly’ in the last two days,” Sherman said. “I’d make a lot of money. (Sports commentator) Stephen A. Smith was on George Stephanopoulos yesterday, and it was just amazing. He’s railing on about this guy, and then every fourth word he had to throw in ‘allegedly.’

There’s also this observation:

“I spend a lot of time discussing what’s wrong with social media, what we shouldn’t be doing, best practices,” said Kerry Rego, a Santa Rosa-based social media consultant, author and instructor. “But I’m a hopeful person, and when I see something amazing and wonderful that social media is a big part of, I spend much of my time discussing that to inspire people in what can be done. Yes, everybody takes photos of their coffee and takes selfies, but they also can change the world with these tools.”

It definitely changed Sterling’s life.

 

‘Best magazine writer ever’: Gary Smith to retire from Sports Illustrated

High praise from someone who was pretty good himself at Sports Illustrated. If Gary Smith isn’t the best magazine writer ever, then he is at least in the team picture.

Writes S.L. Price at SI.com in a tribute to Smith:

Smith’s 13 selections in The Best American Sports Writing is a record, as are his four National Magazine Awards. When he won his first, in 1992, for Shadow of a Nation, he beat a stunning piece written for Life — by Gary Smith. All too often the man was competing only with himself.

Smith, 60, has decided to retire from SI and magazine writing, to focus perhaps on books or something entirely different. For the last six years he has taken to going, once or twice a year, on a silent retreat. “Just figuring out how the mind works,” Smith says. “Turn the lamp inward and watch the mind and what it does. We’re just a piece of the universe, and you can start to get a glimpse of how it all works if you can get the mind quiet and still enough.”

Price writes:

It’s no exaggeration to say that every sportswriter of a certain ambition and age — let’s say from 20 to 70 — has had a Gary Smith moment. This is not fun. What starts as excitement soon becomes a swirl of puzzlement, awe and surprise; the frantic fluttering of pages forward and back; the parsing of sentences like so much Kremlinalia; some involuntary, half-baked blurts like, “How did he…?” and “Why did no one else…?” — and all of it leads back to you, you sorry bastard, and how you’re never, ever going to write a story like that, so what were you thinking getting into this business in the first place?

Since youth is the time of prime vulnerability, such a moment always hit fresh-faced Hemingways the hardest. Mine came at 23, when Smith’s cover story in the Nov. 18, 1985, issue of Sports Illustrated began like this:

When Dale Brown was nine years old, he set fire to the building where he worked. He didn’t mean to. Something he didn’t understand drove him to strike a match in the furniture warehouse and light the piece of straw sticking out from the leg of a chair. It made him feel fearless and free. Suddenly the chair was in flames and the feeling was gone. He raced into the street unnoticed, up the stairs to the family apartment just a few doors away, and into the bathroom.

He pulled down his pants, sat on the toilet and put his head in his hands, heart hammering, each scream of the sirens. …

Indeed, to read Smith was to take a ride into a place you never had experienced in the pages of a magazine. His long tales and unique style weren’t for everyone, and Price writes, he occasionally had some misses.

But more often than not, you were at once riveted and blown away by what Smith produced.

Sports Illustrated will be tweeting out his best stories today. Here are a few:

Fallen coach George O’Leary.

A cover piece on troubled high school basketball star Richie Parker.

Muhammad Ali’s entourage.

 

 

 

 

Would mainstream newspapers, networks have run with ‘alleged’ Sterling recording?

I saw this passage in Bryan Curtis’ piece in Grantland on the media coverage of the Donald Sterling saga.

We have finally blown away the false politeness of the old sports pages. Sports pages weren’t all bad. They could be very good. But they practiced a certain “civility” of speech and they erected Green Monster–sized walls to get news into print (a secretive TMZ recording wouldn’t have passed muster) and they enforced the dreaded “stick to sports” ethos. 

Interesting comment on the TMZ recording and how it wouldn’t have passed muster with newspapers. Curtis, though, is wrong to signal out newspapers here. I have a feeling his home team, ESPN, also would have had some trepidation going with the tape.

Indeed, while watching the coverage yesterday, I struck by the repeated use of  “allegedly” in discussing Sterling by ESPN analysts and elsewhere. Wish I had dime for every time I heard that word.

Even this morning, two days after the story broke, ESPN still was using “purportedly” in its graphic for the story. Check video above.

TMZ, a gossip site, didn’t use “allegedly” in its post. But other outlets were making sure to cover their tracks in case the tape was a fraud. Nobody wants a lawsuit from Mr. Sterling.

It all poses the question of whether more traditional newspaper and network outlets would have gone with this story, given the somewhat uncertainty over the tape. I would think there would be more caution than perhaps what TMZ exhibited.

Listen, TMZ has lawyers too. The outlet had to feel certain knowing they had the goods on Sterling.

Curtis, though, should be reminded that ESPN had the jump on the Manti Te’o story, but the network lost the scoop to Deadspin because it didn’t feel it had everything nailed down.

This is about a lot more than newspapers.

 

 

 

 

 

Did Phil Mushnick really write Sterling shouldn’t be held accountable because he is 81?

Phil Mushnick takes great pride in playing the role of the contrarian, but really about Donald Sterling?

In his column this morning–and by the way this wasn’t the main topic–he had this passage about the Clippers owner.

Longtime NBA followers, executives, employees and media know Clippers owner Donald Sterling as a moneyed fool. Not a terrible man, but a jerk with dough who likes to show off, pop off and, increasingly, think too late, if at all. He’s someone best — and easily — ignored, especially at 81.

Well, not anymore.

Yes, what he allegedly said was painful, indefensible and inexcusable, except why would we expect him, at 81, to be less loony and more discreet and clear-headed than he was at 75 or 78?

Visit any assisted living facility. Or think of that aunt or uncle all of us have known and suffered with a wince because we knew they were off. And they come in all races.

Not everyone, at 81, should reasonably or humanely be held accountable for whatever ugly comments come out their mouths.

At least keep that in mind.

Well, yeah, there are people who in their 80s say cringe-worthy remarks. However, given that people are living longer than ever, there are many 80-somethings who could run circles over 20-somethings, at least mentally.

Also, most 81-year-olds don’t own a NBA team.

Not sure what Mushnick’s intent is here, but giving Sterling a sliver of an excuse for his outrageous comments isn’t going to go down well. As you would expect, Mushnick is getting hammered on Twitter.

 

Feherty lands a top guest: Himself; Charlie Rose to interview him on tonight’s show

David Feherty has interviewed former presidents (Bill Clinton) and former basketball coaches (Bobby Knight) and some golfers too for Feherty on the Golf Channel.

Tonight’s show (10 p.m. ET) might feature its most compelling guest: Feherty himself. For all the laughs on the outside, Feherty is a highly complicated individual who continues to fight many interior demons on a daily basis.

NFL on Fox: Banking on Dallas to be good; 5 doubleheader games for Cowboys

If you thought NBC did the highest ratings for the NFL on Sunday, you’re wrong. Fox Sports’ NFC doubleheader package, which it markets as “America’s Game of the Week,” is No. 1; last year, it averaged 27.2 million viewers per telecast.

Fox is ready to cash in again.

Best games: Fox will go all-in with Seattle and San Francisco.  Fox opens with a San Francisco at Dallas doubleheader game in week 1. Cowboys at Seattle on Oct. 12. Seahawks at Philadelphia on Dec. 7. Obviously, Seattle at San Francisco on Dec. 14 could be huge.

Potential clunkers: Fox also is going all-in on the Cowboys. Dallas is slated to appear in five doubleheader games. If the Cowboys are underwhelming, a definite possibility, Fox will have to adjust.

Fox also has the Giants featured in several doubleheader games, including a trip to Seattle on Nov. 9. By then, New York could be done, forcing Fox to audible.

Bottom line: Fox could use good years from both Dallas and the Giants.

 

NFL on NFL Network: Not so attractive helping of Jags, Bills, Browns, Raiders in second half

The NFL Network is along for the ride this year. CBS will air the first seven Thursday night games with a simulcast on NFL Network.

Then NFL Network will air the remaining Thursday night games exclusively in the second half of the season. However, CBS still will handle the production with Jim Nantz and Phil Simms on the call.

NFL rules mandate all teams play a Thursday game. As a result, the NFL Network slate has several potholes.

Best games: Not much. New Orleans at Carolina on Oct. 30 looks good. Dallas at Chicago on Dec. 4 has some potential.

Potential clunkers: Where to begin? Cleveland at Cincinnati on Nov. 6; Buffalo at Miami on Nov. 13; Kansas City at Oakland on Nov. 20.

And the best thing that can be said about the Tennessee at Jacksonville game on Dec. 18 is that the weather should be nice in Florida.

 

Women at work: Burke shines as ESPN analyst in NBA playoffs; only female announcer in pro baseball looks to make mark

A couple observations about women getting their shots in sports media:

******

Saturday, I tuned into the Atlanta-Indiana playoff game on ESPN. Mark Jones called the game with Doris Burke serving as his analyst.

As usual, Burke was spot on with her analysis. She knows the game and is terrific in breaking it down.

Nothing new here, which is just the point. A female analyst  for a NBA playoff game doesn’t qualify as news anymore. Oh, I’m sure there were detractors on Twitter, likely the same people who still are upset that women got the vote.

But thankfully, there’s a been-there-done-that element to this story. That’s a good thing.

Burke’s next game as an analyst will be Thunder-Grizzles on Saturday night.

*******

Shortly after listening to Burke, I read Manny Randhawa’s story at the National Sports Journalism Center at Indiana on the only woman announcer in pro baseball. Randhawa writes:

She’s the only female play-by-play broadcaster of any affiliated professional baseball team in the country. And take note of her name, because you could be hearing a lot more of it in the years to come.

Kirsten Karbach is the play-by-play voice of the Clearwater Threshers, the Class-A affiliate of the Philadelphia Phillies. She graduated with a mass communications degree in 2013 from the University of South Florida, where she gained experience in production and broadcasting.

Later he writes:

Karbach has her sights set high, and hopes to continue breaking barriers in the world of play-by-play broadcasting along her path. A job calling major league baseball is her ultimate goal.

“That would be the ultimate goal, definitely,” Karbach said of reaching the big league booth. “I’m really happy where I am now, but if I was looking into the future, I’d just hopefully progress in minor league baseball and get to the big leagues, because baseball is definitely what I’d like to be doing. I like broadcasting in general, but baseball is where my knowledge is and where my experience is, and definitely where I want to be.”

For all the aspiring female broadcasters out there, Karbach has a word of advice.

“For female aspiring broadcasters in particular, I would just say, don’t think it’s something that you can’t do,” she said. “Because when I was a broadcaster at my student station, a lot of the girls that came in wanted to do sideline reporting. Not a lot of them wanted to attempt to do color and play-by-play. I personally think that sideline reporting is where the standard is set and that’s why a lot of them aspire to that, but if they like doing play-by-play, they shouldn’t think they can’t.

“Because they can. And it’s awesome.”

During the winter, I taught a graduate level sports journalism class at DePaul. I had five aspiring women sports journalists in the class.

I thought of them as I watched Burke and read the story about the young woman baseball announcer. Throughout the class, I kept telling my students the opportunities are there if you want it bad enough.

Burke and Karbach prove my point.

 

Ryan Dempster joins MLB Network in time to celebrate Wrigley’s 100

Good timing.

From MLB Network:

*******

MLB Network today announced that veteran MLB pitcher Ryan Dempster has joined its roster of on-air talent as an analyst. A frequent guest on MLB Tonight and Intentional Talk with Chris Rose and Kevin Millar, Dempster will appear across MLB Network’s studio programming and make his debut tomorrow, April 23 live from Wrigley Field’s 100th anniversary celebration during High Heat with Christopher Russo at 1:00 p.m. ET and Intentional Talk at 5:00 p.m. ET.

MLB Network’s coverage of Wrigley Field’s 100th anniversary on Wednesday will also include the national telecast of the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chicago Cubs game at 2:00 p.m. ET (game subject to local blackouts).

A two-time National League All-Star, Dempster won 132 games and saved 87 games during 16 seasons as a starter and a reliever. He pitched 200 innings or more in seven seasons, including two seasons with over 200 strikeouts. Dempster began his career with the Florida Marlins (1998-2002) and Cincinnati Reds (2002-2003), and after undergoing Tommy John surgery in 2003, Dempster spent nine seasons with the Chicago Cubs (2004-2012) before joining the Texas Rangers (2012). After starting 29 games in 2013 for the Boston Red Sox, Dempster closed out Game One of the World Series against the St. Louis Cardinals, on the way to the Red Sox’s third championship in ten years. In 2000, Dempster received the James “Tip” O’Neill Award from the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame, and he was the Chicago Cubs’ nominee for the Roberto Clemente Award for community service in 2006 and 2008.